CASE STUDY 1: MOO
It was unfortunate that they didn’t make new science anymore. I could only imagine how thrilling it must have been to discover heliocentrism, or DNA, or orgasms. Galileo, I realized, died so that one day Moo could fart on the great man’s picture in my textbook.
“Here you go,” he sighed, passing it back to me like a handkerchief.
Moo was so insufferably thick I once had to read three books to recuperate from a single conversation. He wasn’t popular enough to be a proper bully but he was far too powerful to go unnoticed, much like Mussolini in his early years. My analysis of Moo was as follows: He compensated for a turbulent home life by being a tyrant elsewhere. Meanwhile, being a level-headed person myself, I chose to compensate for mine by analyzing others and occasionally stealing Mars bars from Rite Aid. I also believed he secretly could not read. My evidence being: He never fully closed his mouth, his real name was something of an urban legend, and even his cleverest jokes were all about foreskin. Given the choice between complete social alienation and befriending Moo, I would have gladly retired to a hermitage.
To the untrained eye, I could also be considered a delinquent. Evidence being: I occasionally wandered the halls, I was not particularly kind to teachers, and my clothes were several sizes too small. Nonetheless, this claim would be completely false, because, unlike many delinquents, I enjoyed reading a good book and had an extensive vocabulary. For instance, I often referred to our school trips as academic excursions. One such excursion was to the planetarium, although it was December and the only things people should do in December are sit in bed and think about how they’re going to stop sitting in bed next year. Nearly the entire sophomore class went, with the exception of Teresa, who stayed home to look after her sad, wealthy mother. My grandmother was disgusted by this; she said people like us couldn’t afford to be sad. I had news for her.
The ride on the charter bus—during which we were all poisoned by Moo’s flatulence—was exhausting enough, but the flashing blue lights inside of the planetarium were enough to knock me out. I looked around at my classmates, all drooling at the sight of a supernova. I thought about how easily we could be entertained by flashing lights and moving shapes; I made a note to record Jeopardy! later. Under the guise of going to the restroom, I squeezed through the aisle and made my way out of the theater entirely.
Outside, it had stopped snowing but I could still see my own breath. The planetarium was built on a large field of grass, which was now a large field of white. I stomped around for a few paces and ran into Moo perched atop a boulder. I stood in front of his throne.
“What are you doing here?” we both asked. Then silence.
He moved to make room on the boulder and I climbed over, oddly flattered. He simply said, “Planetariums are stupid.” I concurred. I sighed and the vapor was enough to cloud my whole face.
“The snow makes me think,” he said. “I get real thoughtfullike.”
“Let’s hear it.”
“Everybody we know’s sitting in that building right now watching the stars on some slab of wall,” he said. “When there’s real stars all around us, for free. We’re just getting dumber and dumber.”
I concurred.
“Where are you always going,” he asked. “When you leave class?”
I said, “Around.” He kept looking at me, so I added, “Bathroom, vending machine. Sometimes I watch the swim team.”
“That actually sounds nice.”
“It is.”
He grabbed a stick and pointed it at the snow, moving it around elegantly until it formed a mushy penis.
CASE STUDY 2: ANDREA
I’d woken up in cold sweats, nearly in tears from a series of unbelievably vivid nightmares, which my grandmother later told me was a side effect of my obsessive cheese-eating before bed. I was wiping off the remainder of the morning’s cheese sweats when my bedroom door flew open.
“Can I borrow a dollar?” Andrea asked, blocking the doorway with her skinny little arms.
“Are you actually going to give it back?” I asked.
“Can I have a dollar?” she asked. I shoved my way into the hall. Andrea was nine years old and already on her way to becoming a master word-manipulator. Sometimes I could tell that people felt sorry for us because we didn’t look alike and because our grandmother smoked. I felt sorry for us because we’d run out of milk. The three of us lived together in a milkless little house. Every night, the walls and stairs would creak at the smallest of movements. The wood was shrinking now that it had begun to snow, and just walking to the fridge would make the entire house erupt into a Vesuvius of groans. If you listened closely, you could make out actual words—words like caterwaul and wordsearch and (my favorite) senile. We couldn’t reach a consensus on what—or indeed who—was behind the talking house. I suspected faulty wood and paranoid delusions. Andrea thought we might be living with angels, a notion my grandmother refused to entertain. She had taken us to church a few times but it didn’t stick. She said she was glad we didn’t take to it, because neither did she. She didn’t like to pray; she liked to make demands.
Our grandmother—she was our shared mother’s mother—took blue pills for her hip. Once, I swallowed a couple to feel something different. Nothing happened, but my hip felt brand new. She was much more skilled at hiding her medicine now.
After I’d recovered from the previous night’s dreams, I joined them at the breakfast table with a cup of black coffee. I’d recently begun forcing myself to enjoy the more odious things in life, such as starting my day with a few sips of molten sludge. I was an intellectual, that much was certain. But now I got to be a tortured one. With a smile on her face, Andrea ripped into her plate of fried eggs. She ate full meals, she sang her sentences, and she always danced on the tips of her toes. Given the evidence, I’d deduced that Andrea was a surprisingly happy child for someone living with the two of us. I didn’t want this to change; we had enough tortured people for one household.
My grandmother blew smoke toward the ceiling and told us some antiquated story about how she’d once known a girl who had gone so long without moisturizing, they’d used her elbows when they ran out of chalk. She gave me a pointed, smiling look—of course. Now we were running late. Of course. My grandmother got up to clear the dishes, and slipped a clementine into my hand. She rubbed my back in a way that said please don’t get scurvy and please do something about those ashy knees and I love you.
Andrea and I walked out the front door and the porch’s wooden steps let out a groan that said anus.
CASE STUDY 3: TERESA
My commute to Teresa’s house involved a bus, an alleyway colonized by stray dogs, then a short sprint to avoid her neighbors, who were Russian and also racist. The houses were massive. The mailboxes were painted bright pastel colors that reminded me of antibiotics—Teresa’s was seafoam green, the Russians’ was baby pink. The grand foyer was an abyss of framed family photos and embroidered pillows. They were great fans of the inspirational quote. Her father had once given me a card that said: Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly -Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Happy 14th birthday from the Goodwins! Like her mother, Teresa was tall and beautiful in a cold, regal sort of way. She was my best friend.
Teresa’s parents were not just rich, they were wealthy. I was beginning to suspect that being born into money gave you some sort of advantage in life. Last year, during lunchtime, we had to discuss our career goals with a counselor. When it was my turn, I walked into a room that smelled like tuna and sat in front of a woman who looked like Humphrey Bogart. When she suggested I consider vocational school, I told her I was interested in something a bit more enlightened and she looked at me in a way that said you are going to be poor forever. I walked out with a paper stamped TEACHER. It seemed fitting: a job where I could be enlightened and poor. Teresa’s evaluation said she would be a lawyer, which made hardly any sense at all.
“It makes perfect sense,” she said.
“No, it doesn’t.” I shook my head. “You don’t know the first thing about law.”
“Well I object to that,” she said, then laughed in surprise. “Look, it’s happening already!”
I was so miserable I could hardly finish my pasta salad, but I did.
We sought career guidance elsewhere. The Woman, whose gender and position were as her name suggested, ran a covert palm-reading operation out of a parking garage facing the river. The first time I paid for her services, I was told that my estranged father, a used-car salesman, had been worshiped by thousands in a past life. I was also warned that my heartline was broken. The bill was what my grandmother would call highway robbery.
We went to see the Woman after school. Surrounded by a legion of Honda Civics, Teresa wrung her hands and tapped her feet.
“Just give it to me straight,” she said. “Am I gonna have money?”
The Woman kept her eyes closed. “Patience.”
Teresa paused for a second and started opening and closing her mouth like a fish. “So is that a no?”
“Just shut up, will you?”
Without looking at her palms, I analyzed Teresa right then and there. Even if having loaded parents didn’t work out for her, that nose was definitely going to get her far in life. She glanced over at me, nervous, in the bright red glow of the taillights. I pinched her arm and she pinched mine.
We both left the garage disappointed. The Woman had told Teresa she would become a wealthy housewife like her mother, and told me that I emitted a deeply bitter energy. We’d been conned. I could have told us all that for free.
CASE STUDY 4: ELIJAH
Elijah’s house was at the top of a steep hill, so visiting him always left me sore. His bedroom smelled like American Spirits and the ocean breeze air freshener he used to try to cover it up. He always acted as if he was being watched. I think he liked having me around.
CASE STUDY 5: MR. MULLINS
We had a school assembly at the beginning of the new semester about how we’re all supposed to stop calling each other gay. In all fairness, the whole gay thing had lost its novelty after a while anyway. Our principal delivered this stirring speech—her name was Mrs. O’Reilly, a woman whose face was like a big beige wall and whose car was always breaking down in the faculty parking lot. Mr. Mullins, whose sexuality had been the subject of great speculation, scratched his knee and checked his watch the entire time. Moo traced the letters G-A-Y on someone’s back.
“And don’t go trying to use any of that fancy slang either,” O’Reilly said, wiping her arm across that wall of face. “Because we will catch you. And there will be hell to pay.”
I raised my hand, genuinely inquisitive. “Would you care to demonstrate some of those words for us today, Mrs. O’Reilly?” I scratched my chin as if I wanted nothing more than to get to the bottom of this. I was let off with a warning but had to spend the next week eating lunch in Mr. Mullins’s room.
It all felt a bit like being left alone with a distant relative; he asked me about my friends and my grades, and his breath smelled deeply of coffee. His eyes were sunken in, so I knew the coffee wasn’t doing its job. He seemed like the kind of man you’d invent if you’d never met a man before, like a child’s drawing of their father. I conducted a silent probe of his classroom. A sky-blue poster with the words I’m an English teacher, YOU do the math! Oh I was doing the math all right. A bowl of candy, presumably for his students; a whiteboard with the objective of the day being please read; a notebook on his desk with a doodle of a man who looked a lot like himself, shouting I QUIT! What I gathered about Mr. Mullins: He seemed to enjoy his job a fair amount. The jury was still out on whether or not he was gay.
On day three, he asked if I wanted to watch a movie. We watched something French, even though I told Mr. Mullins that if I wanted to do so much reading, I’d pick up a book. He loaded the VHS player and wheeled the TV cart closer to where we sat. The tape he chose didn’t come from the stack on his shelf but rather from his own satchel, which made me feel embarrassingly special. Antoine, misunderstood and a Parisian (I commiserated with him on both matters), finds himself alienated by his teachers and his family. It was all achingly shot in various shades of gray. At the end of the film, he goes sprinting away from school until he reaches the beach. He stands in the water and looks miserably into the camera.
I wasn’t sure what Mr. Mullins was trying to tell me with this film. He handed me the VHS to keep and I chose not to tell him that we didn’t have a tape player at home. We lived off of basic cable. The bell rang before I could say anything anyway.
I walked into his classroom the next day and saw that the TV cart was still there.
“Got another one for you,” Mr. Mullins said with a smile. “And it’s in English!” He’d become less of a distant relative—a kind uncle, maybe. The objective of the day was: study for quiz tomorrow!
“English,” I said. “My favorite.” I sat down in my usual seat, a chair right across from his desk. The film was about a young man and an old spinster who disgust everyone around them by falling in love. The young man pushes his car off a cliff and plays some Cat Stevens. I liked this ending a lot more than the last one. I was still in a post-movie daze long after the credits were over, and on my walk home later that day, I found myself humming. I began arriving early to our lunch meetings and leaving late. Years ago, my third-grade teacher handed me back my poem about the misery of growing old with the word thoughtful! written at the top in red. Until I met Mr. Mullins, that was about as close as I’d gotten to teacherly bonding. Or critical acclaim.
At our last lunch meeting he gave me half of his pastrami sandwich, which I understood as a token of great respect. He held up his half and said, “Bad for the heart, good for the soul.” I imagined us on a pamphlet advertising the school: Where great friendships are made. I imagined him as the president of a polite, soft-spoken country. I asked him what his slogan might be.
He swallowed and thought for a second. “Um, probably, uh, a vote for me . . . is a vote for me for president.” I imagined it on a T-shirt. We ate in a pleasant silence.
“You should keep doing all that reading,” he said when I got up to leave. “I imagine it’s probably good for you.”
CASE STUDY 6: ELIJAH, AGAIN
Elijah had dark hair, which meant he was ruggedly handsome. And he was left-handed, which meant he had a feminine side. He wasn’t afraid to use big words. I met him on one of my expeditions around the school grounds, when I loitered by the pool watching muscular boys bob up and down like muscular ducks. He appeared out of the water like my own little surprise. Standing by the glass doors, I puffed air into my cheeks and motioned for him to hold his breath. I didn’t get to see him again for another five minutes.
He occasionally read the classics, which meant he was sensitive. Once, Elijah and I fell asleep on the floor after a long day of doing nothing and I got carpet marks all over my cheek. Or really, only I had fallen asleep—I woke up to find him on his bed, reading Kafka’s journal. He was under the impression that he’d never experienced anything Kafka hadn’t. I found this highly irritating. That night, after we kissed for the first time, he was turning those pages furiously, looking to find out if Kafka ever made out with some girl after watching Attack of the Mutant Toddlers. Then, a week later, he wanted to know if Kafka had ever spent several hours in the dark with some girl and a flashlight, analyzing a Playboy. Amazingly enough, Elijah teased, he had.
We gave up on the magazine. We’d flipped through what felt like an endless lineup of images—cowgirls and chefs and maids and firewomen and teachers and doctors and painters bent over and looking, jaded, into the camera. I suggested they unionize. Elijah pointed the flashlight at me and my eyes began to sting. I smiled when they watered. I turned the spotlight on him and began making shadow puppets on his face. Turning my fingers into a barracuda proved tricky but it got him to laugh. I conjured up a little dove next, right between Elijah’s eyes.
He walked me home. Each time the light went red and we had to linger a minute longer, my heart melted into my shoes. I willed the red hand to go up; I didn’t pray, I made demands. But the light switched and a glowing white man appeared—motionless, yet he seemed in a great hurry. Elijah bent down to tie his shoelaces and I pretended not to notice they were already done. Flakes of snow landed on my eyebrows. We walked about two steps a minute, like little tokens in a game of Monopoly; he was marching me straight to jail.
The street lights created Ferris wheels in his enormous eyes. Elijah was the kind of person to let himself be interrupted, which worked out perfectly because I was the kind of person to interrupt. Sometimes, like when he walked me home that night, we didn’t speak at all. Only in his company did I have nothing to say, and I was relieved. The little white man returned and we started moving again. The arms of our coats were touching; the friction produced tiny flares and sparks. Here we were, creating new science.
CASE STUDY 7: GREG
Greg lived right across the street. Greg had some sort of mental illness that made him develop a British accent two months ago and my grandmother said I was not allowed to question it. It wasn’t a fancy accent either; it was deeply Northern.
I was also not allowed to laugh at anything Greg said, so I was never sure how to react to his jokes. I figured the best thing to do was stare at him until he walked away. He was about fifty years old and lived alone, so I deduced that he was a divorcé, and a recent one at that. Greg was my favorite person to analyze because I knew next to nothing about him. For instance, I assumed his last name was adventurous and European, like De La Fontaine. Gregory De La Fontaine. I could only imagine the ex-Mrs. De La Fontaine was a suburban socialite, the kind of person who owned a vanity plate; they weren’t married long enough to have children; he was only in the throes of this separation for a matter of days before consummating his wild affair with his caregiver; she wore a small nurse costume and they fed each other strawberries. I’d read somewhere once that strawberries were a powerful aphrodisiac.
My grandmother began to grow weak. She held my hand while the doctor told us some words I was embarrassed not to understand. At first, I spent my evenings looking after her, then I eventually threw in my afternoons and—while I was at it—my mornings. She started talking as if something bad might happen, like a fallen soldier in a movie.
We spent an entire night watching Jeopardy! until she noticed a little yolk of sun through the window and turned the TV off. I had gotten the Final Jeopardy twice: Adolf Hitler and Dijon mustard. I began to ask what she thought of my budding brilliance when I noticed my grandmother’s eyes were closed.
“I wish I gave you a better mother,” she laughed. I wasn’t sure what to say. I wasn’t sure what Andrea and I would do. I patted her hand and began to clear up all the used tissues and empty teacups. I wished she would stop looking at me. I wasn’t sure what Andrea and I would do.
I took time off from school, though I hoped they would manage without me, and stopped answering Elijah’s calls. On the wooden steps of our porch, I sat on my hands and watched Gregory De La Fontaine smoke a cigarette. His skin and hair looked even whiter in the cold. The road between us was a miserable puddle of gray, now that all the snow had started to melt. His nurse had arrived an hour before so I assumed the cigarette was post-coital.
“Those aren’t good for you,” I shouted weakly.
With the flat vowels of his new accent, he said, “Right then.”
I watched him drink it in until he reached the filter. He flicked the stub onto the puddle-street and strode away, presumably to catch his lover in time for round two. It was refreshing to see, really.
My vocabulary, extensive as it was, had its limits. I confused words like narcoleptic and apoplectic. They all sounded made-up to me. If only I’d been a walking thesaurus like Elijah. The word for someone like that was sesquipedalian, that much I knew. Analyzing people was fun, but learning felt like survival; I began finding new ways to describe all the little horrors. Elijah was an ignoramus cockalorum for leaving me. My parents were introuvable; Teresa’s were lugubrious. My infelicitous grandmother became bedrid. In time, Gregory became a boon companion. I watched him smoke and roam the streets nearly every day, piecing together new parts of his backstory each time. He was a retired intelligence agent; his diet consisted of little more than cigarettes and strawberries, but more than anything, he craved justice; he wished he could see that vanity-plated car drive past him one last time; he wished he had children. My grandmother could hardly keep her soup down. I once caught Gregory sleeping on a park bench.
Narcoleptic—that’s when you’re always dozing off.
Teresa made her way over to my neck of the woods to check up on me and drop off some missing assignments. I was abashed to have her sit on my twin bed. She asked me if my grandmother was getting any better and I said, “Boy, this chemistry homework is exigent.” She nodded as if she might secretly be analyzing me. From the pocket of her coat, she produced a Mars bar.
“The staff at Rite Aid missed you,” she said. Though I’d only gone two weeks without seeing her, I couldn’t help but look at her like she was an interloper from my past. Just the thought of it made me feel guilty. Then she said, “How’s your imaginary friend doing lately?”
“Okay well—” I scoffed. “You’re making it sound like I’m some sort of nutcase.” I scoffed again. “He lives in 238.”
“Gregory De La Fontaine does?” she laughed. The sound made my mouth taste like pool water.
“No, Greg does.”
Apoplectic—that’s when you’re really angry.
I left for the kitchen and grabbed the Mars bar on my way out.
Pat Sajak narrated my chores. I disposed of the empty water bottles on my grandmother’s bedside table. Andrea sat on the floor, holding her hand and reading out the clues. “No, you don’t have to answer it with a question,” Andrea whispered to her. “I think that’s the other game.”
I looked out the window, across the street. He’d gone for a stroll the previous afternoon and I hadn’t seen him since.
Back in my bedroom, Andrea stood eagerly before me. I remembered when she used to do ballet. Now, like some sort of sadist, she wanted to be a dentist. For a second, I let myself think about how I was going to have to raise her right. She smiled at me and her teeth were perfect, though some were still too large for her head.
“Ice cream truck’s here,” she said, extending a sweaty little hand. “But there’s a moving truck blocking it. U-Haul. You Hall. Yoo Hull.”
I handed her a dollar. “Give me back any change. Who’s moving?”
“Mr. Nelson—U-Ball. U-Stall. U-Wall.”
So there was someone in the neighborhood I never knew. I was surprised. “Who’s Mr. Nelson?”
“From 238,” Andrea said. She bolted out the door, toward the fading, tinny song of the ice cream truck. “U-Small, U-Tall, U-Called . . .”
I sat on the porch and waited for something to happen. The home across the street was vacant. A family of silverfish traced the shape of my shoe, back from a winter of hibernation. The trees had turned green again, just for them. I swayed side to side on the wooden steps, hoping the house would tell me what to do. If this were a film, it might groan out something like joy. Or a Cat Stevens song would start playing. Instead, the wood just squeaked under my weight. I rocked back and forth, waiting. The house had nothing to say.

